Sunday, August 03, 2008

On Oil Prices, Inflation and Sustainable Development

This article is the child of a discussion me and a few of my friends had recently. The arguement was basically about whether oil prices in India should be subsidised or not and are these prices and inflation related.

First a few graphs:




First graph shows the inflation pattern over the last few years, the second shows where we are compared to the world and the third is perhaps what caught my attention the most; credit and deposits variation over the years. Clearly they point out the same thing; that somehow whatever stock markets rises we have experienced in the last 10 years has not been out of sustainable development. We suddenly opened our doors to the global contenders and that has had an adverse affected our economy. How many students today opt for courses like B.Sc in Agricultural Sciences? We are a big nation, we cant possibly mimic countries like Japan, France, Germany etc. They can forgo agriculture and concentrate completely on processing industries. We on the other hand have such great raw material resources which are now left to waste silently or exported to some other country where they add huge value to it and sell it back to us. The students cant be blamed either, they want job safety and will take up paths that get them there. Nobody can worry about the nation with a hungry stomach unless its a revolution. The way I see it, we are not amidst any revolution, rather we are caught in global currents and being drawn into serious troubled waters.

One more interesting graph would be :

Education has been the worst hit. Inflation in tuition fees means people will opt out of higher studies. With engineering colleges springing up like mushrooms all over cities, how many students can actually be employed? Though loans are available, without jobs students can do nothing but see the interest piling up.

Thanks to the banking policies where getting loans are often more easier than opening a savings account. They play on our disires and we make our lives more and more miserable by giving in.


At the end of the day, if this were to be just a phase, then we could have held on tight to the ship. But if were have been sailing without a bottom all along, then what element of truth exists in all the passionate statements made about our country's progress? I still feel, though with all the emotionless policies, China has done much better. Sustainable development has lost its meaning completely. Bangalore has had such a huge influx of the poor from Bihar, UP etc that I am tempted to say that slums in Bangalore will surely compete with Mumbai, soon enough. With growing disparity, if the economical policies are not balanced then there is no hope for more than 70% of the population. Only a small class of city dwellers have had such a hike in their purchasing power that even if oil prices are doubled they would still be coughing out smoke with their sedans.

A few methods we thought were reasonable were:
1) Remove subsidy on oil for private use, but subsidise public transport and household LPG. That way we could reduce unnecessary usage of oil for personal comfort yet keep common men afloat.
2) Increase the taxes in MNC's.
3) Improve the food storage. So much of food material rots in basements while people go hungry in India. The distribution and storage is incorrigible.
4) We are going for N-Deal but we have so much scope to improve our powere distribution grids. The the transmission losses if reduced can light up many more villages and reduce load shedding.

4 comments:

  1. not my piece of cake..
    but liked it...seriously no one opts for courses like agricultural sciences these days

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Sharkey. I have insane amounts of time to blow, so lemme argue at length. :)

    Clearly they [the charts] point out the same thing; that somehow whatever stock markets rises we have experienced in the last 10 years has not been out of sustainable development.

    Um, how exactly? Stupidity in national oil price-regulations implies that what development we've had isn't sustainable? And so far as I know, inflation wasn't much of a problem until the last 2 months or so. And the graph there doesn't even talk about those two months.

    Also, the growth in credit vis a vis deposits is a direct result of softening interest rates - it no longer makes sense to save as much as before, and it's easier to borrow. The way you should look at loans and savings is that if you take a loan to purchase a commodity (that say for sake of argument, increases your standard of living,) then you enjoy that high standard of living for more time than you would have if you had to save up money till you were rich enough to procure the same commodity with a single payment. Credit isn't as evil as traditional Indian mentality makes it out to be. :)

    Regarding education, the per capita availability of college seats has gone up many fold since 1995, and it can be argued that it is these extra seats, which weren't even available earlier, that are responsible for increasing the college education inflation rate. The increased inflation rate is also perhaps because of reduction or stoppage of central govt. subsidies on tuition fees in aided and national institutions. State govts still subsidize quite a bit though.

    Will write more when I think of something. :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. my gawd sharkey !!! tht was .... umm... seriously one to make u think...

    ReplyDelete
  4. "Remove subsidy on oil for private use, but subsidise public transport and household LPG. That way we could reduce unnecessary usage of oil for personal comfort yet keep common men afloat."

    Dude without an efficient public transport system this move is not feasible.And right now the public transport system in our country is crap. Even the capital of our country is pretty shitty in this matter. Lots of money needs to be invested in public transport and accompanying infrastructure before doing away with subsidies for private use.

    ReplyDelete